| See also: Spin Different. Friends: Downing Street (UK) & The UN Secretary-General |
![]() Unofficial blog of briefings from Tony Snow and friends at the Whitehouse. Based on DowningStreetSays.com. |
|
|
Whitehouse ListWhitehouse Press Briefings with alerts and comments - for you to read and respond to what the Press Secretary actually says, rather than what they were reported as saying. If you spot any problems or have any comments, drop me an email |
Press Briefing by Tony Fratto
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Good afternoon. I just have just one quick announcement for you on a -- FEMA will be hosting a conference call this afternoon at 2:00 p.m. to talk about the federal response to flooding. This will be at 2:00 p.m, and if you just check in with FEMA and they'll get you the information for call-in and they'll tell you about the whole federal response to the region affected by the flooding. Yes, Terry. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q On the President's offshore oil statement today, it didn't seem like he really wanted to cooperate...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q On the President's offshore oil statement today, it didn't seem like he really wanted to cooperate
Q Well, since it's clear that Congress is not going to do what the President wants, why doesn't he take the step himself and let the --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: No, I don't think it's clear. Well, people have asked a lot, and I think someone shouted it out at the statement about why doesn't the President just turn -- we talk about this as a two-key operation, you need both keys to be able to open up the OCS to drilling. The President turning his key alone isn't going to do it. But he made perfectly clear that he will turn that key, that he will lift -- or that he will announce the withdrawal if Congress can take action. Now, the part that we're talking about where Congress needs to take action in lifting the moratorium isn't simple. We think it can happen relatively quickly, but there are parts to it that we're talking about that are of great interest to the state, so this has to be a communication with Congress and with the states. And we want to hear from governors, obviously, because we're talking about revenue-sharing for these areas, and we're talking about what kind of limits in terms of where -- how many miles out from shore are appropriate for drilling. And these are conversations that we want to have with states. It would require legislation to work these things out. So we have to do it with Congress. That's where the onus is, and that's where the most complicated part of this is. And I think it might take the President 20 minutes to do the withdrawal over here, but it's a much more complicated and intricate piece involving the various levels of government that we're talking about with Congress. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Tony, the Democrats have made it clear for a long time that they're absolutely opposed to this. ...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q Tony, the Democrats have made it clear for a long time that they're absolutely opposed to this.
Q But one of the people who is saying that something could be done overnight is John McCain, with the tax moratorium. You're not trying to say he's trying to --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: He has a view on the tax moratorium and that's his position, and we talked about looking for it. The President has been looking at it, but what the President has been focused on is the root of the problem, which is supply and demand. And we've done a lot on the demand side, in terms of conservation. We passed an energy bill last year that increased CAFE fuel standards, and that will put billions of alternative fuels out there that our cars are going to run on. We have done a great deal of investment in technologies for long term, for future automobiles and other forms of alternative fuels. That's on the demand side. Now what we really need to do is something on the supply side. I gave the statistic earlier today in the gaggle that over the past three years or so, maybe a little bit longer, the annual -- 85 million barrels per day of oil being produced in the world, and we have seen millions of consumers out there -- in this country and in places like China and India and South Africa and Brazil and Russia and other emerging countries -- that are putting millions of new cars out on the road and they're increasing demand. So we see demand increasing and we're not seeing a corresponding increase in supply. And we have supply here at home and we should use it. Yes, Wendell. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Two questions. First, is there some technical reason that Congress has to act first on the OCS drilling?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: No, I'm just saying that if the President did the withdrawal it wouldn't result in an oil platform going up anywhere along our coastline. We need Congress to take action because they've got the most complicated, intricate part of this. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The second is, there's apparently an EPA draft -- a draft of the EPA's coming report suggests that the agency believes that automakers could increase CAFE standards much faster than the President has called for.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I haven't seen that. I haven't seen any EPA reports, and I'd refer you to them. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Because it hasn't been released yet --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Okay. (Laughter.) Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- and the suggestion is that the EPA Administrator probably will not release that, though the scientists have found that they believe that the industry could, in fact --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I think you're asking the wrong person about a report that -- if it hasn't been released -- and what the EPA Administrator would do, but I'd love to hear what Steve Johnson would have to say about that when he's ready to say something about it. But don't forget that for the first time in 30 years last year, we aggressively increased corporate economy fuel standards, okay. I mean, this was something the President called for, and we were able to get it done. And the President aggressively called for the use of more alternative fuels, and we got that done. In fact, we were pushing further than Congress was prepared to go in this. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Let me try and follow that one more time.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Okay. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q If $4-a-gallon gasoline is enough to make people rethink drilling on the Outer Continental Shelf, is it also enough to make people rethink perhaps raising the CAFE standard requirements for automakers?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: It might, but I'll tell you what -- what you have are knowns and unknowns, okay. (Laughter.) Do I want to go that way? (Laughter.) Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Do you want to go there? (Laughter.)
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I don't know what the technical capability in terms of the internal combustion engine can do in squeezing out miles per gallon. I don't know what the ultimate limit of that is. And obviously there are people out there trying to find that out, and there are people -- the automakers out there are trying to learn this also. With this price of -- the gasoline at the prices they're seeing out there, they're out there trying to find cars that meet the demand of their consumers, of the consumer market. And what they're finding from consumers right now are consumers want lighter, smaller, more fuel-efficient vehicles. And like anyone out there, they're going to -- like any business out there, they're going to try to give their consumers the products that they want to buy. So, yes, that could have an incentive on it, on that end. In terms of drilling, we know where the oil is. As Keith said this morning, a lot of these areas have been previously explored and they had the geologists in there trying to determine how much oil there might be. And so we know it's there and the only thing that's stopping us from getting to it and bringing it to market are these federal regulations. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Tony, even though increased domestic oil production would be years away, the White House position...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q Tony, even though increased domestic oil production would be years away, the White House position
Q You're saying that by Congress acting now, this would have an impact on the market --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Sure. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- because they'll know that there will be an increase in future supply. But at the same time, you're saying speculation isn't a factor.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: That's not speculation. I mean, if you know what the sources of oil production are going to be over the course of, say, 5, 10 or 15 years, and you have a general trend rate of what demand is going to be for global use of something, that's not speculation. That's just trying to have an understanding of -- and trying to price something based on supply and demand. That's an analytical judgment; that's not a speculative judgment. There is speculation on any given day out there, but that's not -- but looking at the future and looking at supply and demand and making an investment decision, that's not speculation. That's just an investment decision like millions of people every day. Now, if you're not basing it on those things and you're basing it on the direction of market movements out there where you see unusual trading, that's something different. That's the kind of things that Walt Luken over at the CFTC is looking into. But there's absolutely no denying that the overall source of price increase in oil globally, and gasoline here at home, is a function of supply and demand. That's the overwhelming reason, that's the core reason. There could be other factors in there. No one is saying that there aren't other factors that could have an impact. But the largest and most significant reason is supply and demand. Ann. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Why is he pushing Congress on this, and not pushing the oil companies that have 33 million acres of leased area that they aren't developing, that's not under the --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: The first step in development in the oil business is actually exploration. They hold these leases -- I've heard people up on the Hill, "the oil companies are sitting on leases", as though the oil companies -- I'm not here to defend oil companies; I'm just telling you that they have every incentive in the world to go out there and pump more oil. I mean, Ann, if you've got -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- without Congress lifting the ban?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I'm sorry? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Are there not leases out there that are not -- that have already proved -- that have not been developed, that they could be doing and they're not doing?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: It's not a question of whether -- oil companies can say that on any given piece of lease that they're holding whether it's productive or not. I'm just telling you I can't imagine an oil company not wanting to produce oil today. And what we see are oil companies out there looking to try to produce and do more drilling. But it takes many, many years, and millions, if not hundreds of millions of dollars to go from a lease to actually pumping oil. So you need to send sophisticated people in there and figure out whether the oil is there and whether you can extract it, and whether you can bring it to market, and do you have the power, and is it a good business decision in the sense of how much it costs to take the oil out of the ground and get it to market. But at these prices -- which no one could have anticipated three, four or five years ago -- I can't imagine the incentives being more properly aligned for oil companies to go out and try to get every barrel of oil out of the ground. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Perhaps I was inelegant in how I asked the question. Are there not leases that are out there that...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q Perhaps I was inelegant in how I asked the question. Are there not leases that are out there that
Q But that's not the point, Tony. The point is --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: It is the point, though. I mean -- I'm sorry, the -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Are the oil companies doing everything they can to explore and drill where they already have permission, without opening up the OCS any more, or ANWR?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I can't speak to every business decision that oil producers make, and I'm not here to defend what they can do and can't do; they can answer those questions for themselves. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Is the President satisfied the oil companies are doing all they can -
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Like I said, I can't imagine their incentives being better aligned than to go out and develop. And I think -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I'm not quarreling with you on that, I'm just saying --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: And I think they are. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But the President is satisfied that he does not need to push the oil companies; it's Congress that's the problem?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Well, Congress is the problem in this case, in terms of the Outer Continental Shelf and ANWR. And also -- do not want to forget the other two proposals that the President talked about today on oil shale and on the refineries. And remember, one of the -- the cost bottlenecks that we have here in the United States has been this inability to produce new refineries or expand refineries because of regulatory hurdles and so forth. So I thought that was also another important -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Uncle. (Laughter.)
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: -- another important proposal for the President. Yes, Roger. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Different subject.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Actually, stay with oil and then -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Yes, go ahead.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Go ahead, Jon. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Speaker Pelosi says, as far as the topic Ann was asking about, that 80 percent of oil available...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q Speaker Pelosi says, as far as the topic Ann was asking about, that 80 percent of oil available
Q Okay, they're not.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I mean, there have been regulatory hurdles with oil shale, and Keith talked about them at -- a great deal today. In terms of the available oil in the Outer Continental Shelf, I mean, that's not -- we have known for years, for 20 years, 30 years, that oil is there, and it has been a moratorium that has kept producers from going there to put up platforms and do it. And look, at that time when oil was relatively cheap, that was probably a sacrifice that the country could make, to say that -- and at the time when we weren't maybe as technologically advanced in our ability to put platforms out there in the water that are environmentally safe. And these firms have learned a lot over the past two decades and three decades about their ability to go out and put a platform in water and extract oil, and do it in a way where they're not causing any environmental harm at all. So now, at this time, where we see oil at $130, near $140 a barrel, and we have come as far as we have in terms of the technological ability to do this right and do it in environmentally friendly ways, we think this is the time to be able to get out to that oil. The strains on our economy are significant, and we need to put ourselves in a better place, and this is one way to do it. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I'll press for documentation from Pelosi's office as far as her claim on the 80 percent, but do you guys have information, statistics to verify --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: The Energy Information Agency over at the Department of Energy, and Department of Energy can give you every data point they have available. They'll be more than happy to do it. Yes, Victoria. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The President took a fairly aggressive approach towards Congress this morning, and he says he wants to work with Congress on this issue. Did he really strike the right tone if, in fact, he wants to get business done with Congress?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Okay, you know, I'm always amazed by these kinds of questions, where the President states a matter of fact, and the matter of fact is that Democrats in Congress have opposed this policy in the past for a very long time, and we need to work with Congress to try to get things done. That's a basic statement of a matter of fact. In anything we do involving legislation, it's just what the lay of the land is, what our position is, what their position has been, and how we need to get to a successful place. The things we hear coming out of Congress sometimes are pretty caustic and vitriolic, and I never hear anybody coming up here and saying, do you think that what members say about the President will harm our ability to get something done? I could tell you, we -- whether we want to work with Congress, we need to work with Congress. It's the only way to get this moratorium lifted, and we're willing to and ready and able to do that, and that's our goal. Anyone on oil? I can take one more on oil and then -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Just on the Jeddah conference.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Yes. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Can you talk about the expectations for that, now that that delegation has been announced?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Well, look, I think we want to learn a little bit more from the producers and consumers there about how the market is operating. No one is expecting to see announcements of increased production. We'll want to explain our view of how the markets are operating in terms of supply and demand, and also in terms of some things that we think would help, like transparency and greater investment in oil exploration and development around the world. So those are some of the things that Sam Bodman will be talking about, and we'll see what comes of it. Okay, Roger. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The war supplemental is up in the House tomorrow. What's the White House position on that? Because it's got the GI Bill feature in it --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I haven't seen -- yes, I haven't actually seen legislative language on it. I mean, our position -- you know our position, it's been the same for a long time, that we want to see -- we don't want to see any language that ties the hands of our commanders in the field, and we want the funding. And on the GI Bill, the President wants to have a GI Bill. He talked about it. We have been having conversations with sponsors there about ways that can meet what the President needs. Now, what the House has done apparently is come back -- or plans to come back with the identical bill that failed last time they brought it. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q It's got the unemployment benefits part in it, too, which was veto bait --
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Yes, we were -- I think we made our position clear on unemployment insurance. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q So he would probably veto it then if the House passes that version?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: If it's the same bill that they sent up last time, I think you can expect that. Les. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Thank you, Tony. Two questions. The AP reports that Senator Obama said that Osama bin Laden is...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q Thank you, Tony. Two questions. The AP reports that Senator Obama said that Osama bin Laden is
Q All right. The Oklahoma House of Representatives, by a vote of 92-3, passed a resolution affirming...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q All right. The Oklahoma House of Representatives, by a vote of 92-3, passed a resolution affirming
Q Can you take a look at it and give us some information on this?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Maybe. Maybe I can. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q There are reports in the Israeli press that the U.S. is mediating between Israel and Lebanon over Shebaa Farms as an effort to get peace negotiations started. Comment?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I don't know that I can put it that way. I don't know enough about the nature of those discussions. But obviously we want to see those border issues resolved, and if they're able to do it that's something that would be good for the neighbors there. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Can you tell us anything about the meeting the President has with the Chinese delegation today?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: He'll have an opportunity to just talk about the U.S.-China economic relationship. They're here meeting as part of the Strategic Economic Dialogue that Treasury Secretary Paulson put together -- and a large number of our Cabinet are involved in these discussions with the Chinese -- and just talk about the importance of the economic relationship. So that will be occurring over at the EEOB. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Thank you.
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: I'm sorry, can I just grab Brianna because -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Tomorrow President Bush is awarding the Medal of Freedom to General Pace. And in the past when...
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. Q Tomorrow President Bush is awarding the Medal of Freedom to General Pace. And in the past when
Q Is this the last briefing of the week? Are you going to brief on Thursday with the trip, and Friday's trip?
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: You're right. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Bye. (Laughter.)
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Is that "bye" or "good riddance"? (Laughter.) Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Just "bye."
seen at 09:00, 18 June in Whitehouse Press Briefings. MR. FRATTO: Okay. Read more Comment (0), Email this. |