See also: Spin Different. Friends: Downing Street (UK) & The UN Secretary-General
The Government Says
Unofficial blog of briefings from the Whitehouse. Based on DowningStreetSays.com.

Whitehouse List

Whitehouse Press Briefings with alerts and comments - for you to read and respond to what the Press Secretary actually says, rather than what they were reported as saying.

If you spot any problems or have any comments, drop me an email

Email me when appears in a briefing. Email:
Statement on Federal Disaster Assistance for Nebraska
seen at 17:14, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Dana Perino
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Okay, I've got two things for you -- I said I would have the radio address preview and tomorrow's commencement address. In this week's radio address the President will outline several important legislative matters pending in front of Congress and note the dwindling number of days they have left in session to get this work done.

He will call on them to pass a war supplemental that focuses on the needs of our military; to support our military families by passing an extension of the GI Bill that makes it easier for our troops to transfer unused education benefits to their spouses and children; ensure that our intelligence professionals have the tools to monitor terrorist communications effectively and quickly -- that's the FISA law; approve the Colombia free trade agreement, which would open a growing market for American goods, services and crops; confirm nominees to important government positions, including Steve Preston, who the President nominated to be the next Secretary of Housing and Urban Development; pass legislation to modernize the Federal Housing Administration; reform Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, to ensure they focus on their housing mission; and allow state housing agencies to issue tax-free bonds to refinance sub-prime loans. And at a time when Americans are concerned about gas prices, Congress needs to pass legislation to expand domestic energy production.

Tomorrow night the President will travel to Greenville, South Carolina to deliver the commencement address at Furman University. It is a speech that calls on students to help build a culture of responsibility. It will reflect on how he went into public service because he was concerned about the culture and how he is heartened by the progress that has been made, especially in the young people who are embracing bedrock values of faith and family. He will talk about the importance of service to others, including volunteering and military service and being a part of the faith-based communities; contributing to the civic and economic life of the country by voting and public engagement and entrepreneurship; and being accountable to your family and to yourself -- parenting, strengthening the family and living lives of integrity.

That's it. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Congressman Wexler has called on Scott McClellan to testify before Congress, and Congressman Conyers...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Congressman Wexler has called on Scott McClellan to testify before Congress, and Congressman Conyers

MS. PERINO: I checked on it for you. The White House Counsel's Office takes these things when we have a formal request. We don't have a formal request yet. When we get one, that's when we look at the request, weigh it fully -- as we do with all the others -- and it's just not a decision that we would make prior to getting a formal request. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Could the White House block him from testifying if he wanted to testify? Or how does that work?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Conceivably? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Yes.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Hypothetically -- which I'm not supposed to answer hypotheticals -- (laughter) -- yes, I think so. The law would allow for that, but by saying that I'm not suggesting that that's what would happen or not happen. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Has President Bush read this -- read McClellan's book or does he have any intention to, to sort of find out what this is all about?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Well, he's been regularly briefed. I think he's read a lot of the articles about it, but I don't anticipate -- he may or may not read the book. I don't know, we haven't talked about that. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q You haven't bought it for him?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: No. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Has he expressed any kind of feeling about it?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Sure, as I talked to you about all week long -- I know I haven't been here for you, but we were out on the road -- (laughter.) Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I'm trying to make a living myself. (Laughter.)
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: We've been out on the road; I've missed the podium greatly. But as I said all along, that the President expressed disappointment and sadness at the situation, surprise by the charges that he has read about that are in the book.

And we've known for a while that this is what the tone of the book would be. Of course last November we knew because of the excerpt that came out, and then more recently, as with all manuscripts, the White House Counsel's Office has an opportunity to look at manuscripts for any possible classified information or any means for executive privilege to be asserted. None of them were in this case. So we've known for a little bit of time that this was coming. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q This morning you said that this wasn't about the messenger, it was about the message.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Sure. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But isn't it precisely about the messenger, because those criticisms that Scott raises in his book -- they've been out there -- usually they come out of the mouths of Democrats -- but they've been out there. So isn't it precisely --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: That doesn't make them true. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But what I'm saying, though, isn't it the fact that a former member of the inner circle is saying...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q But what I'm saying, though, isn't it the fact that a former member of the inner circle is saying

MS. PERINO: I don't believe -- no, and I don't think that any time that we have argued about this that we've argued just about the messenger when it comes to Democrats either. We argue about it on the merits. And our central objection to the book to the book is that it is not based in fact.

And I think that one of the reasons we are puzzled and surprised and disappointed and saddened by it is because the charge, the loaded charge, in the book is that the President and his senior advisors purposefully misled people into war, and that we sent our young men and women into war, knowing something that we weren't telling the American people.

That is not true. And several independent non-partisan reviews have been done about pre-war intelligence. Is it true that WMD wasn't found? Of course it was. And we admitted that. We have said over and over that the intelligence was wrong. And we have worked very hard at President Bush's direction to change the way the intelligence community works together. But what hurts us is the suggestion that we purposefully sent men and women to war without acknowledging the consequences. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q But he makes a number of charges, and not all of them are that direct. For instance, he says the President engages in "self-deception." And that's not something that may be willful, but it still has significant consequences.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I think it's an outrageous claim. I've been here myself for a long time, almost as long -- I've known the President not as long as Scott has, but quite a long time. This is a President who is -- I've never witnessed any self-deception at all. I think it's an absurd claim. And it's such a loaded charge. And you're right, when it comes from somebody like Scott, who was a close friend of many of us here at the White House, those of us who fully supported him before, during and after he was press secretary are disappointed by this and saddened by it. We certainly wish him well. We harbor no ill feelings towards him. We just are really disappointed, and we're going to combat the central premise of the book.

And I don't -- again, when you say that it's different because it's coming from him and not the Democrats -- I've always argued about this on the merits, so regardless of where untruths come from, we're going to push back on them. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q One more. Just in terms of sort of the ongoing battle for public opinion, people who have been ...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q One more. Just in terms of sort of the ongoing battle for public opinion, people who have been

MS. PERINO: I think that's giving this book a lot more weight than it actually carries.

Martha. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Can we just talk about what isn't true in the book? I mean, you go to the part about weapons of...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Can we just talk about what isn't true in the book? I mean, you go to the part about weapons of

MS. PERINO: Not that I'm aware of. But did we communicate about the war? Yes. And I would point you to the President's speeches -- all the speeches that the President made leading up to it; he made several comprehensive speeches making the case for why Saddam Hussein was a threat, which was, based on the intelligence that we had -- and not only the United States had, but that's what the world had. And in addition to that he talks about -- in his speech especially on February 26, 2003, when he spoke to AEI; it was before I was a part of the press office, so I would encourage you to go back and look at it, as I've had to do myself -- where he talks about that the benefit to a free Iraq would be to the Iraqi people and also to the region, and establishing a change in the Middle East when it comes to freedom and justice and democracy. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q But the order of what was talked about at the time in the buildup to the war was largely about weapons of mass destruction.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I think that that was -- well, I think you could go back, you could weigh it -- you know, I'm looking at it, what I have seen is a comprehensive case for confronting Saddam Hussein, and that's what the United Nations of course was talking about, specifically weapons of mass destruction. But there was also a gathering threat in terms of the nexus of working -- for example, paying suicide bombers, paying families of suicide bombers.

And you know better than anyone, Martha, about the buildup to this, the reaction to this. The problem that we have is this -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q There were no suicide bombers in Iraq.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: But paying them in the Palestinian Territories and in Israel. That's something that Saddam Hussein himself said. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Just a general question, then, Dana. I mean, one of the things he talks about is spinning, exaggeration, I mean, what goes on at the podium -- which is an indictment of you, as well. Do you think there's no spinning?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: You know, it's a term that I don't necessarily use. I come out here, I answer your questions, I answer them to the best of my ability based on the information and the facts that I have. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Define your job for me. I know Scott in the book says that his job -- he believed his job was to advance the agenda of the President of the United States.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Sure it is. That's part of it. And my job is to be his spokesperson. But I also, as many of you in this room know -- especially you -- that I work very hard on behalf of the press as well. I defend the press, I advocate for the press and I make sure that all of you have answers as quickly as possible to the best of my ability every single day -- Saturdays and Sundays included.

Ann. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q In the book it reports that there came a time when the administration ignored contrary evidence...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q In the book it reports that there came a time when the administration ignored contrary evidence

MS. PERINO: No, I don't necessarily think so. Again, I wasn't here, but I would point you to -- at least three that I can think of -- independent reviews of pre-war intelligence and the decision to go to war that all came to the conclusion that nobody purposefully misled anybody in this endeavor. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q When you say that we've known for a little while that this was coming, was the manuscript well circulated within the --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: No, it was close -- it was tightly held. And in fact I haven't read the whole thing myself. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But when you said "we knew," who was "we"? Was it the Counsel's Office?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: The Counsel's Office is the recipient of the manuscript. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Was the President aware? Was the Chief of Staff --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: As I said, he was briefed about it by members of senior staff who were aware of it, but it was very tightly held thing. It was not circulated and of course I think you can know that it was pretty tightly held from our end because we didn't get -- we didn't give any reporters or anyone else outside the information or the manuscript. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Do you know whether anybody contacted Scott McClellan about the content?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I don't know for sure, but I don't believe so.*

Mike. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Dana, you've used words like "sad" and "disgruntled" when talking about Scott and the book. Do you have a sense of his motivation after a few days of this back and forth about --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I'm not -- I won't question his motivations. He's free to have his opinions and he's free to have a look back at his period. I think one of the reasons I think it's sad is for those of who worked with him and saw how much he loved being press secretary, and how much he loved being a part of the back and forth in this room, and how much he delved into policy and tried to understand it as best as he possibly could, that to realize now that he looks back and looks so unfavorably upon his time at the White House -- I think that's one of the things that's really sad.

I mean, all of us are moderately talented people made very special because of an opportunity, and, you know, you can choose to use that opportunity in any way that you wish, and he's chosen this path. It's not a path that I will choose, that many others have not chosen. But I think that this is quite a unique circumstance, and I think that's one of the reasons it's sad. He's obviously very displeased and discontented with his time here. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q How about the idea of somebody from the inner circle writing a book, whether it's a Republican ...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q How about the idea of somebody from the inner circle writing a book, whether it's a Republican

MS. PERINO: I think there's something to be said for that. I think that one of the things that you have in any organization -- be it your news organizations when you have editorial meetings or here at the White House, but especially here at the White House -- that you want to have some level of trust that when you speak up, that it's going to be held in confidence; when you push back on something, that that is held as -- in confidence. And if it's not, I do think that that's difficult for people necessarily. But I don't know of anybody at the White House who is sitting around a room thinking, oh my gosh, is he taking notes and going to report on this later? I think that is one of the reasons, when I say we were so surprised -- and not just puzzled, in terms of surprise -- at the tone of this book, of the language that he chooses to use; that's what is so disappointing and surprising to us. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Are you surprised he might vote for Obama?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I really don't care who he votes for.

Connie. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Sorry you're on the hot seat on this, and excuse me if you've already been asked this at some point, but if you -- have you harbored any doubts about the war, and if you did, would you speak up, and would you resign?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Well, frankly, Connie, this isn't about me. Whether or not I -- what I care -- what I think on any issue is of no interest to any of you -- maybe until I leave and write a book -- (laughter.) But my job -- any press secretary's job is to articulate the President's positions and message, and answer your questions. And that's what any press secretary is supposed to do. So I'll continue to do it for the next seven months, or for however long he'll have me here. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But if you have a crisis of conscience, what is --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Have I had a crisis of conscience? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And if so, what is your obligation --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: No, I have not. But I think that if I feel the need to speak up at any of the number of meetings that I have, or my -- if I need to step through the open door that the President has provided for me, I will do so without any concern about my future. And I have -- you have to be confident in going out -- coming up here every day, and I am. I have no crisis of confidence. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, let's just broaden it. If a staff member has doubts, do they have an obligation, any staff member, to speak up --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: They have to all make that decision on their own.

Anybody else on this? Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Dana.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I'm going to go here to Jim. You had one this morning.

Go ahead. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Is there -- has the White House gotten involved in the Fulbright situation with the students in the --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: In the Palestinian Territories? I saw that report this morning. Obviously we want people in the Middle East, students in the Middle East, to be able to come to America. The President thinks it's critically important to have that type of exchange, cultural exchange, between American students and the Palestinian students or Middle Eastern students. And in fact it's one of the things he talked about in the World Economic Forum speech just a couple of weeks ago when we were in Egypt.

It's something that he has asked Secretary Rice and Secretary Spellings to specifically concentrate on, and Ambassador Hughes when she was here. And we have made strides. But I think Hamas obviously has made it very difficult for students to be able to take advantage of the opportunities that present themselves, like the Fulbright scholarships. I don't specifically have information from the White House, and I'll have to refer you to the State Department for anything more on that. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Dana -- and I'm sorry if it was addressed this morning; I apologize --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: It's okay. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- does the White House have any response or further response to the allegations of the Commerce Department computer being hacked into while in China? Have you talked with any agencies involved, or with China?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I would refer you to the Department of Commerce on that. I don't have anything specifically here. I know that they are looking into the matter over there, and for security reasons we don't comment on particular matters that are being investigated. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But is it a concern to the White House that something like this --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Well, we are continually working to increase our capabilities to make sure that all of our information is safeguarded; that any cyber risk that is out there we take into account, and we are constantly trying to work on it. Other governments are, too, so we take that into account. We're always looking for ways to safeguard our systems and we'll continue to do so. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Dana, a question. Is the President satisfied with the response in the private sector to safeguard computer networks?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I've not heard him say otherwise. I don't know. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, certainly this is a major concern, particularly with the utilities.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Well, I think that private sector corporations are probably just as concerned about their own information as we are here in the government. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But there have been reports that the private sector hasn't done anywhere near as much as the government has to safeguard --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I just don't -- I don't know. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q If it were ever to be shown that a power failure like the one that hit the Northeast in 2003 was the result of a cyber attack, would the President consider that an act of war?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Wow, now that's a hypothetical I'm not going to answer.

Olivier. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Dana, I have a couple for you. One is do you have a reaction to the cluster bomb vote?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: The one from yesterday -- or was it two days ago? I can't remember; it's been kind of a long week. Well, we are deeply concerned about the humanitarian impact, not only of just cluster munitions, but really the whole range of munitions that are used at war. It's a moral obligation to clean up, and we do so. You need to try to do everything you can to clean up after a conflict zone to make sure that there aren't innocent victims that are hurt with unexploded weapons that are lying around on the ground.

We've played an important role in it since 1993. We've spent more than $1.2 billion on such cleanup. No other country in the world comes close to that. We are strongly committed to working to address this problem. I would refer you to the State Department because I believe that they will be able to articulate for you some of the disagreements we may have with the tactics or the venue for addressing this problem. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q And this morning you said you would assume that Prime Minister Olmert would be welcomed here next week. If he shows up at AIPAC at the event --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I would expect that if he comes to the AIPAC conference that the President would meet with him. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But it's not -- so it's not on his schedule? And would they meet at the White House, would they meet in another setting? What was the --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: I don't think the President has any plans to be anywhere but the White House next week for any sort of meeting. So if he comes, it would be here at the White House. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Okay, but it's not on the schedule then as of right now?
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Not that I know of. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Dana, two quick questions, please. One, as far as Scott is concerned, we all have known him very...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Dana, two quick questions, please. One, as far as Scott is concerned, we all have known him very

MS. PERINO: I think I'll just leave that one alone. What's your second question? Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q And second one is that, as far as terrorism is concerned in Afghanistan and on the Pakistan border...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q And second one is that, as far as terrorism is concerned in Afghanistan and on the Pakistan border

MS. PERINO: What's your question? Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q So where do we stand now? Is President briefed on all this, where we stand now --
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Yes. You might not have heard, the President this morning spoke to President Musharraf. That was followed on his meeting with Prime Minister Gilani in Sharm el Sheikh, which was just a couple of weeks ago. We are very concerned, but we believe that the Pakistanis are, as well, and that we need to continue to make sure that we can confront the terrorists there on the border. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Wait a minute, Dana -- Dana.
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MS. PERINO: Okay, can we do one? It's decision time. (Laughter.) Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I have one question that has nothing to do with your -- (laughter.) This morning The Washington...
seen at 09:00, 30 May in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q I have one question that has nothing to do with your -- (laughter.) This morning The Washington

MS. PERINO: Certainly not. I think it's referring to the U.S. Air Force Academy commencement ceremony, and the President had a wonderful time with 1,012 cadets, personally acknowledging each of them. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

 Copyright Statement and About "The Government Says".