See also: Spin Different. Friends: Downing Street (UK) & The UN Secretary-General
The Government Says
Unofficial blog of briefings from the Whitehouse. Based on DowningStreetSays.com.

Whitehouse List

Whitehouse Press Briefings with alerts and comments - for you to read and respond to what the Press Secretary actually says, rather than what they were reported as saying.

If you spot any problems or have any comments, drop me an email

Email me when appears in a briefing. Email:
Press Briefing by Tony Snow
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: One addition to the schedule for tomorrow. Tomorrow the President will travel to the Department of Homeland Security and visit the Nebraska Avenue complex. He'll receive a briefing from Secretary Chertoff and other senior-level employees on their priorities and efforts to guard against the threat of terrorism and keep America safe.

As you know, the global war on terror is a struggle against terrorists who are threatening the entire civilized world. While men and women in the military are fighting abroad we've got to make sure that we continue to fight them at home. And the men and women of the Department of Homeland Security are essential in that fight. So we hope to have pool coverage at the end. We'll give you details on coverage as they become available.

Questions. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Tony, the President said in his speech on the 10th that America will hold the Iraqi government ...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Tony, the President said in his speech on the 10th that America will hold the Iraqi government to the benchmarks it has announced. How do you follow through on that pledge if Iraq is not meeting its own target dates for certain pieces of legislation, they're not supplying troops into Baghdad at the numbers that were expected? What does the White House do to follow through? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What will happen then?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, we hope that we'll be able to report success. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But even that drawn-own process doesn't do much to address the lack of security for the people who are needed to rebuild Iraq in places outside the Green Zone. And as you know, there's difficulty getting those people to go there.
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Yes, there is, absolutely. We're in the process right now of working on building up the provisional reconstruction teams. The State Department pretty much has its commitments now made. Their team leader positions are pretty much filled. The President, in the Cabinet meeting the other day, made it clear to members of the Cabinet that we need to be able to get people in place, and we've also talked about a civilian corps that would be able to provide some of the services we need.

Force protection is clearly a priority, not merely for the military, but for the people working on the PRTs. But the Department of State, the Department of Defense and other departments, other Cabinet-level departments and agencies, are working toward getting them staffed up, because there also is a significant return, once you do start creating economic opportunities and jobs. And I know you've seen some of the research on it, which indicates that it does have a significant impact on reducing violence. You have a situation where once you do have the ability, first, to clean and hold neighborhoods -- or clear and hold neighborhoods, it does then give you the opportunity to follow on.

What we are not doing is putting provisional reconstruction teams in hot zones. But the plan is, you go in, you go in with force, you stay in on a 24-7 basis, you clear the neighborhoods, you also work on developing the trust and confidence of those -- then you start flowing in with the forces that do the economic support. So we're keenly aware of the security challenges. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q You've got a chicken-and-egg question here. I mean, you can't get people in there because it isn't secure.
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, keep in mind, the security part is the first -- as I just explained, when you're working with the U.S. and Iraqi forces going in district by district, you do the clear and hold; and then at that point you start bringing in the other infrastructure, the provisional reconstruction teams. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And that's taking a lot of time, a lot more time than people --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, it's still worth doing. It's an important piece. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What can you tell us about the helicopter that was shot down?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Not much. I'd refer you to DOD. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Was it shot down?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Again, preliminary reports indicate mechanical, perhaps. But again, I just -- I don't -- we don't have firm word on it. And the place to go for a real answer is the Department of Defense. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Tony, are you concerned about these reports that a member of the Iraqi parliament, Dawa party member, ruling coalition, appears to be the same guy that was convicted of those embassy bombings back in '93?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, again, the one thing we've made clear with the Iraqi government, and the Prime Minister has made clear, is that you have a situation now where you have a government that's committed to peace. And people who are operating outside the law committing acts of violence, you're going to need to deal with them. But I'm not going to render judgment on the story. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Tony, this may seem demeaning, but it's obviously a serious question. This NASA scandal is huge...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Tony, this may seem demeaning, but it's obviously a serious question. This NASA scandal is huge all over the world. Is the White House going to ask the NASA for any more transparency in the oversight and selection of astronauts in light of this unfortunate -- ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, even the oversight of the way they select, and then they continue to monitor their astronauts --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Again, Connie, I'm just -- NASA has the answers and the responses to this, and I'd direct you to them. I'm not going to grandstand on that story. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Tony, as far as terrorism, the President going to talk tomorrow. I'm frustrated, as many Americans...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Tony, as far as terrorism, the President going to talk tomorrow. I'm frustrated, as many Americans, that it's been a long time, five years, for General Musharraf to respond not to support the terrorism. So much has been written on this issue

-- clearly indicates also that he is not questionable as far as the support in global war on terror with the United States. Do you think the President is frustrated? Or he still has faith and trust in General Musharraf? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Tony, I'm curious about this Centennial Parks Initiative. This is a time of very tight budget constraints...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Tony, I'm curious about this Centennial Parks Initiative. This is a time of very tight budget constraints; even programs like Children's Health Insurance got only the smallest of increases. I'm wondering what brought on this sort of sudden bout of conservationism and a big increase for parks. ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- talking about the parks --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: No, the first thing we've got to do is to talk about the assumption of the question, because it was an argumentative assumption that I think is worth at least trying to pick apart, as well.

The President has been committed to conservationism since the beginning of this administration. Last year, for instance, we set aside the largest natural wildlife reserve on the face of the Earth. This is not new. Just as many people have been saying, wow, isn't the President -- isn't it nice that the President has finally agreed that global warming has manmade components, only to find out, because we've been telling you, that he first started talking about it in June of 2001.

There's been a lot of misreporting, or perhaps it just hasn't -- perhaps folks have not taken notice of the fact that this is an administration that's been keenly committed, both to environmentalism and conservationism from the start. This is important -- this is also a plan to work on the national parks over a 10-year period. So what we're talking about is $1 billion over 10 years for the centennial of the U.S. Park Service, which will -- it seems to me that that's a pretty reasonable down payment. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Well, you raise that point about reporting on the President's environmental record. People are starting to say, is George Bush waking up to the environment?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, the fact is -- actually, the question is, are reporters waking up to his five-year record? The answer is, the long national slumber may be approaching an end. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Is there any concern that U.S. and Italian relations are going to be hurt by the Italian judge charging an American soldier with homicide for that --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: I'm not going to talk about any particular judicial activity, but I will note that we continue to work closely with our allies. And many of our -- throughout Europe, our allies continue to supply important aid and assistance in the war on terror, and that's going to continue. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Lawmakers have been going after Secretary Paulson up on the Hill in the hearings the last few days...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Lawmakers have been going after Secretary Paulson up on the Hill in the hearings the last few days on the budget, particularly the AMT fix, saying that the administration has used the revenue after '08 to balance the budget. Do you think that's a fair criticism? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But, Tony, if the administration believes in cutting taxes, why didn't the administration propose a legislative fix

--
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.

MR. SNOW: Well, I think you understand, what's happened is it's a pretty hot topic and a lot of members of Congress, I think, at this point, are going to want to talk it through. So let's see what members of Congress have. What we're doing is we're trying to be deliberative. We have now created and opportunity -- we've basically created a space, a 20-month space, in which members of Congress can avoid trying to sort of score quick political points and instead do something that's responsible, because millions of Americans now have suddenly become alive to the fact that this is a tax increase that's been sort of snuck in.

And by the way, a few years from now, if Congress does not extend tax cuts that are now in effect, they're going to have a similar unpleasant surprise when tax cuts expire. So the President has, in fact, been talking with Congress about a series of things: holding taxes down, extending tax cuts, working on the AMT, and also the kind of budget discipline that's going to make it possible for us to do this without raising taxes on Americans. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Just one question, though. Do you acknowledge that just the one-year fix, and nothing -- and being silent in the off-years helps show a balanced budget by 2012?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: No, what it means is it gives us the basis for working forward on it. Obviously, this is part of the balanced budget, but what I've just told you is the principle of revenue neutrality remains in effect. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I had a couple questions on -- the first being a response to what you just said a moment ago. ...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q I had a couple questions on -- the first being a response to what you just said a moment ago. Are you saying, then, in terms of the President's position on greenhouse gas emissions, that five years ago you said with 90 percent certainty -- contributes to greenhouse gases -- ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, in respect to opposing views, companies such as -- Energy, Whirlpool, are coming out and saying we need mandatory federal constraints --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, they're talking about carbon caps. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- is the administration meeting with these groups at all, these groups that believe that mandatory -- whether it's a carbon tax, or --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Yes, as a matter of fact, if you'll recall, one of the first trips -- it may have even been the first trip right after the State of the Union was to DuPont, which was one of those companies. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Greenpeace has signed on to nuclear?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: I think there's some Greenpeace people who are certainly advocates of nuclear power. Why? Because it's clean and it provides for energy. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I'm sorry -- did they discuss greenhouse gas emissions at that event?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: I don't know. I don't know. Paula, we constantly have conversations with people on this, as well as with scientists. And I think what you're trying to do is to lend the impression that if a President does not meet with people who are corporate leaders, that somehow that issue goes unexamined within the administration. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Again, think about what happened. In the Clinton administration they went -- they talked about Kyoto and did nothing to get it passed, knowing what kind of a ruinous economic impact it would have. What we did is instead, we said, we believe in the goal -- and early on, the President talked about the linkage between climate change and the human elements -- and began to proceed on the most aggressive program of research and technology ever, when it comes to this.

And furthermore, on the negotiation side, not only are we talking about follow-on negotiations when it comes to climate change with our allies, we've also been dealing with the developing world, which was not at all included within Kyoto, offering them technology, and really taking the kinds of steps that demonstrate real seriousness, not simply giving the speeches, but walking the walk.

So the idea that somehow we are -- that we don't understand the arguments, or we're not contemplating or taking serious the arguments about carbon caps -- of course, we are. I would point out that the carbon -- that there is a carbon cap system in place in Europe. We are doing a better job of reducing emissions here. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Thank you. Tony, an advance team is reportedly on his way to Central and South America to prepare...
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Thank you. Tony, an advance team is reportedly on his way to Central and South America to prepare for the President's special trip there next month. Is he going? And what about a stop in Puerto Rico? No President has visited there in more than 50 years. ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Does the President think it's a good idea that Speaker Pelosi have a large government military jet available to her to back and forth to California?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: After September 11th, the Department of Defense -- with the consent of the White House -- agreed that the Speaker of the House should have military transport. And so what is going on is that the Department of Defense is going through its rules and regulations and having conversations with the Speaker about it. So Speaker Hastert had access to military aircraft and Speaker Pelosi will, too. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Does the United States have moral obligation to refugees from Iraq? And if so -- refugees from the war in Iraq, which there are now a couple million almost in Syria and Jordan -- and if so, why have we accepted so few?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, I don't know if you saw this, Wendell, yesterday, but the Secretary of State has, in fact, announced the creation of a working group on the problem. I don't know if it's a moral obligation, but it is certainly an obligation that we think is important to take up. I think to the extent that we believe there's a moral obligation to reach out to those who have been displaced around the globe -- and the United States is usually the first to the scene -- we certainly are interested in trying to work with regional partners to deal with those who are there. We're also trying to work with the Iraqis to create better conditions on the ground. But it is a problem. And as I said, the Secretary yesterday announced a program for addressing that and will continue to do so. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q That does not indicate that we would accept any more than the --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: I just don't -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- the tiny handful that we've accepted in this country.
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, again, I would refer those issues over to State. That is -- no, I would. If you want an answer to it, call them. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Let me try and bring it home here.
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Okay. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Gerald Ford made a commitment to accept Vietnamese refugees. Is the President willing to make the same commitment?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: As I said, I would refer -- right now this is being done in a working group at State. And so we're not in a position to make any announcements at this point of that sort. But why don't you give them a call? They may be able to -- literally be able to give you better context and texture about this.

Paula. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q I just want to make clear something about 2001. Wasn't this President's position then that, yes, he acknowledged there is global warming, but there's too much scientific uncertainty as far as how much of it was human-generated?
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: Well, again, go back to the statement. He talked about -- there was a certain amount of uncertainty about the percentage that is human-generated, and there continues to be controversy in scientific circles. But what the President said right then and there was that human behavior was a significant contributor. I don't know how to make you happy. When he says exactly what you've been wanting him to say, it turns out he's been saying it actually over a six-year period, I think you'd say, okay, I need to give him credit. And instead what you're saying is, well, golly, didn't he say what the IPCC said in 2007? I mean, come on, give us a break here. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- on global warming, do you have any reaction to some apparent comments by Al Gore in Spain in an interview, where he suggested that the administration is paying scientists to dispute the global warming findings --
seen at 12:24, 7 February in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. SNOW: The reported remarks by the Vice President that the United States -- that the government is going out and paying money to those who dispute climate change research is just breathtakingly silly. I think maybe what he's done is he's mixed up a story about a think tank in Washington with government policy.

As I've said, this administration has spent more money than his administration and any other administration when it comes to doing serious, peer-reviewed scientific researches on the nature, causes and extent of global warming, and also has spent far more money on technology to try to ameliorate it without throwing people out of work.

The President really does believe that it is important to address climate change, and, incidentally, to address issues of pollution, as well, on the industrial side, on the transportation side. And that is why he laid out a whole series of initiatives in the State of the Union address. Those really build on the efforts -- and, again, just to reiterate, $9 billion for basic research when it comes to climate change, and $29 billion total on that research, plus technological innovation designed to make sure that Americans do get -- that we address carbon emissions, we address issues of pollution and, at the same time, we do it in a way that continues to make economic opportunity possible for everybody. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

 Copyright Statement and About "The Government Says".