See also: Spin Different. Friends: Downing Street (UK) & The UN Secretary-General
The Government Says
Unofficial blog of briefings from the Whitehouse. Based on DowningStreetSays.com.

Whitehouse List

Whitehouse Press Briefings with alerts and comments - for you to read and respond to what the Press Secretary actually says, rather than what they were reported as saying.

If you spot any problems or have any comments, drop me an email

Email me when appears in a briefing. Email:
Remarks of the President in Welcoming Senior Staff and Cabinet Secretaries to the White House
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 11/22/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 11/17/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 11/10/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 11/9/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 11/04/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/28/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/26/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/26/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/19/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/14/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/12/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/7/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Statement by the Press Secretary, 10/5/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/4/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 10/1/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/30/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/21/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/17/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/15/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/9/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/7/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 9/2/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 8/30/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton and Assistant to the President for Counterterrorism and Homeland Security John Brennan, 8/24/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Gibbs and Secretary of Homeland Security Napolitano, 8/13/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 8/11/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton Aboard Air Force One en route Austin, Texas, 8/9/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 8/5/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Presidential Nominations and Withdrawal Sent to the Senate, 8/5/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Presidential Nominations Sent to the Senate, 8/5/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 8/4/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, Admiral Thad Allen, Carol Browner, and Dr. Lubchenco, 8/4/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Presidential Nominations Sent to the Senate, 8/3/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 8/3/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Gibbs, Ron Bloom and Ed Montgomery, 7/29/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/27/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/26/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/22/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/21/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Daily Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/19/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/14/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/13/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 7/12/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 7/9/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 7/8/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 07/07/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs and National Incident Commander Thad Allen, 7/1/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 7/1/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton Aboard Air Force One en route Wisconsin, 6/30/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 6/22/2010
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
President Obama Announces More Key Administration Posts, 6/18/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Readout of the President's Call with Lakers Coach Phil Jackson
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Weekly Address: President Obama Says Republicans in Congress Blocking Important Progress
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Información Sobre La Reunión Del Presidente
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs Aboard Air Force One En Route Louisiana
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs and National Incident Commander Admiral Thad Allen
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 6/9/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Briefing by Press Secretary Robert Gibbs, 06/10/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle Aboard Air Force One by Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton, 6/14/10
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Deputy Press Secretary Bill Burton aboard Air Force One en route Columbus, OH
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the First Lady to the Camp Pendleton Community
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President at a Gulf Coast Briefing in Gulfport, Mississippi
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President After a Roundtable Meeting with Local Residents in Gulfport, Mississippi
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President After Touring Theodore Staging Facility
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President After a Briefing with Admiral Thad Allen and Local Officials on the BP Oil Spill
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President at an Event with Military Personnel in Pensacola, Florida
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President to the Nation on the BP Oil Spill
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Statement by the President After Meeting with BP Executives
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President to the American Nurses Association
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Remarks by the President at the Site of the 10,000th ARRA Road Project
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Trent Duffy
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Let me update you on the President's day. This morning he taped his radio address on the outlook for the year ahead, which includes focusing on our country's top two priorities, which are winning the war on terror and keeping the American economy growing strong and creating more and more jobs.

He then had his normal briefings, which included a briefing on both the wildfire situation in the Southwest, as well as the flooding and rainfall in the Pacific Northwest. As you know, the Agriculture Department issued a press release two days ago that outlined some of the federal government resources that are being applied in the wildfire situation.

He then did some brush clearing and just completed a bike ride before I came out. This afternoon he's scheduled to sign several pieces of legislation which several of you have been inquiring about, including the Patriot Act extension, the Labor-HHS appropriations bill, which does include the provision on the citizenship of Olympic skaters, and the Defense emergency supplemental appropriations bill, which among other things, includes additional aid for the Gulf Coast, as well as the government's preparation for pandemic flu.

Our aim is to have a photo release of him signing the Labor-HHS appropriations bill for your use, should you decide to use it. There will be some other paper coming out today, including the President's New Year's Day message, which we'll release right after the gaggle. And we'll have our normal announcements on all the bill signings that he's done, but there's going to be some paperwork -- we'll try to get it out as soon as we can. I think he'll start signing bills here within the hour. I don't know exactly, but that's kind of the target. So we'll try to get that information out to you as soon as we can.

The week ahead we'll do at the end. I think that's what I have.

Toby. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Is the White House the ones that requested the Justice Department investigation into the NSA leaks?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: No, as the President said, the Justice Department undertook this action on its own, which is the way it should be. The President spoke directly about how he felt about the leaking of classified information, and the White House was informed of the decision, as was the President. And you have his own words about how he feels about the leaking of classified information. I think it's plain to say that the terrorists want to strike America again and they hope to inflict even greater damage than they did on September the 11th. The leaking of classified information is a serious issue. The fact is that al Qaeda's playbook is not printed on page one, and when America's is, it has serious ramifications. You don't need to be Sun Tzu to understand that. (Laughter.)

So the country is at war against a determined, patient, and ruthless enemy, and that enemy attacked America repeatedly and wants to do so again. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Can you give us just some details on when he was informed?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: He was informed today. Yes. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Today?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Yes. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Who informed him?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Senior staff.

All right, week ahead? Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Can you talk about some of the things he's done this week to get ready for '06 and the State of the Union? Has he had people up here in meetings, or has he talked to people on phone conference or videoconference?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I think the best way to describe it is he's just reflecting really on the way we've been discussing, earlier this week, been reflecting back, looking forward. Just like all of us, when you're outdoors and taking a break, you have time to think about things, and that's the process that he's going through. He has spoken, himself, about how he values his time out of Washington, because it helps him stay grounded. And that's really all I have. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Can you tell us -- has he been talking on the phone --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Don't have anything for you on that. He hasn't had any guests that I know of. Just Mrs. Welch. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Any more information about his visit to San Antonio?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: More information on the visit to San Antonio? No. I think, for planning purposes, he may hand out some purple awards, Purple Heart awards -- pardon me. He may present some. And that's really all I have. I think we anticipated that most of the wounded soldiers, as I said earlier this week, are going to be from the Iraq theater, but we'll get more information on that. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Scott had said that the President was not going to sign an extension of the Patriot Act -- temporary...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott had said that the President was not going to sign an extension of the Patriot Act -- temporary extension of the Patriot Act. Were there any sort of discussions of whether or not he should so this after saying that he wasn't going to? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- compromises in that, dealing with congressional oversight -- greater congressional oversight of how the act is enforced?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: We'll continue to work with the Congress as it returns next session. You know the administration's view on how important this is, and to continue to make sure that law enforcement has what it needs to do the job. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Is there anything on CAFTA, on whether or not it's going to be implemented next year, CAFTA?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: On CAFTA? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q CAFTA.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I don't -- see whether it's going to be implemented next year? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Yes, are we ready to implement next year --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: You might want to check with USTR. I'll see what I can find out, Suzanne.

Mark. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Trent, on the Patriot Act, I still don't understand why when the Senate was considering a three...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Trent, on the Patriot Act, I still don't understand why when the Senate was considering a three month extension, the White House threatened to veto, so the Senate passed a six-month extension; then when the House insisted on a five-week extension, the President is now going to accept that. ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The National Response Plan, on Katrina, the lessons learned, when is that?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: The lessons learned review is undergoing -- excuse me, is ongoing. And as the Homeland Security advisor mentioned at the outset of the exercise, she is planning to finalize that in coming, I'd say, weeks. It has been a very productive exercise. She's met with hundreds of officials both in and out of government, and state and local, she's traveled to the region, she has a very effective team of professionals working on this review. They are working out of the Old Executive Office Building, and they're doing an exceptional job. So I anticipate something on that in the coming weeks. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And he still hasn't met with any speechwriters, right, on the State of the Union?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Mark asked that earlier this week, and just to be fair to Mark, I said at the time he hadn't met with anybody this week. He has back in Washington met with speechwriters at least once to begin the process of thinking about the State of the Union. So apologies to Mr. Knoller.

Week ahead?

Okay. Again, Sunday, January 1st, visit to the Brooke Army Medical Center, as was previously noted.

Monday, January 2nd, no public events.

Tuesday, January 3rd, meeting on the Patriot Act in the Roosevelt Room. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Who is that with?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Don't know. I will put that at the end.

Wednesday, January 4th, he will make a statement on the global war on terror at the Pentagon.

On Thursday, January 5th, he will be meeting with the Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, former Secretaries of State and former Secretaries of Defense in the Roosevelt Room. And that will be to discuss the war on terror and our challenges in Iraq and winning the war in Iraq. Then he will have a photo opportunity with the 2005 Little League Softball World Series Champions in the Oval Office. And he will later make remarks to the U.S. University Presidents Summit on International Education -- that's at the State Department.

And on Friday, the 6th, the President will travel to Chicago and participate in a tour of the Chicago Board of Trade, and make remarks on the economy at the Hilton Chicago.

Thank you, and happy New Year. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q On Monday, are you -- is Scott or you doing briefings on Monday, do you know?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Federal holiday. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Sorry, what about tomorrow?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Saturday. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What about the President tomorrow? What is he planning tomorrow?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I just updated you on the President's schedule. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But tomorrow is Saturday, and you started with Sunday.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Correct. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Press Gaggle by Trent Duffy
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Good morning. One update to the President's schedule to inform you about. The President, on Sunday, January 1st, will visit the Brooke Army Medical Center in San Antonio, Texas, where he will visit with wounded soldiers. We anticipate that most will be from Iraq. There may be others, and we'll update you on that at a future point.

The President had his normal intelligence and daily briefings this morning, and was out clearing brush. And that's what I have on his schedule. And that's what I have. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Any update on the Patriot Act? Patriot Act extension, any update on that?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: No updates on bill signings. We'll let you know when he's doing any of that. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Do you expect any other White House aides to come down to the ranch later this week for things like planning purposes, speeches?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Nothing to announce at this point, Roger. If there are, we'll let you know. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What aides were coming down.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: What other White House staff are coming down later in the week. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The New York Times reports today that there are several legal challenges based on the NSA wiretaps. Are you concerned that these challenges could jeopardize the cases against people you guys have already described as very bad people?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Jessica, I think Attorney General Gonzales and General Hayden did a very thorough briefing about the legal underpinnings that the administration is basing this program on. I don't have anything to add to that. And we decline to comment on any pending cases, but I don't think it should serve as any surprise that defense attorneys are looking at ways to represent their clients; that's what defense attorneys do. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Changing topics, whatever happened with the Crawford jury duty, since we're here? Do you have any update on that?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: The last I recall, the President's attorney was working to have that postponed until some later date. And I can see if there's any update on that. But I think it was -- I think they were looking for a postponement after a period of months, and perhaps years. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q That same New York Times article says, there's consideration of filing criminal charges against...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q That same New York Times article says, there's consideration of filing criminal charges against President Bush, himself. Is he prepared to face any possible charges, and what kind of -- the White House must have some sort of reaction to the concern that this could bring this NSA issue into the court and open it up to all sorts of inquiries. ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Are you making preparations in the Legal Counsel's Office to defend this in court?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I don't know how to answer that question. So I won't. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Do you think, though, that the lawyers -- or more specifically, their clients, have a right to know how their cases came to be, and if --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Dana, you're asking in the context of pending cases, and we're just prohibited from commenting on that. So speculating on pending cases is something we can't do. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q You all have talked about cases that are up before the courts before. Just in general, can you say how hard the administration is going to fight the defense lawyers?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I would refer you to the Justice Department for any questions like that. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The President publicly acknowledged the NSA wiretapping in his Saturday radio address. But in subsequent news revelations about perhaps broader surveillance, he's chosen not to acknowledge that. Why the difference?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: The President discussed what he felt comfortable discussing in the news conference, and this is a highly classified, or was a highly classified program and he felt it necessary to discuss that since it was reported. And that's the decision that he made and the administration made. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q How long does the intelligence briefing take in the morning, roughly? And once that's done, is...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q How long does the intelligence briefing take in the morning, roughly? And once that's done, is his presidential work done for the day? Is he taking calls of any kind? Is he still doing official reading, or is he on his own reading list, and is it on to pleasure reading after that briefing is over? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The President had, obviously, a bad couple of months. And I'm wondering how a vacation like this...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q The President had, obviously, a bad couple of months. And I'm wondering how a vacation like this kind of plays into that? Is a vacation like this a time to reflect on the bad stuff that has happened in the administration? What function does a vacation have after just the spate of bad news, be it polls or just a whole variety of things? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Does the President have any plans at all to address any of the folks who are protesting outside...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Does the President have any plans at all to address any of the folks who are protesting outside the ranch? And also, what would be his reaction, or is there any White House reaction, to their calling on him to reflect on his Christian faith in dealings in Iraq and in efforts to bring troops home? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q So he won't go out there and address them, or has no plans at all to --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I think the President has spoken directly and publicly to the American people about why he made the decisions that he did, why it's the right thing for us to finish the job in Iraq, and why it would be a terrible, terrible thing to retreat in the face of terrorism, because it would essentially provide great relief and a victory for the terrorists.

Jessica, number three. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Will his daughters be coming down for New Year's Eve?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: What's that? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Will his daughters be coming down anytime before New Year's Eve?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I'll let you know. I don't know. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And can you give -- share with us his New Year's Resolutions?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I will see. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Trent, on the bill signing, it's not a question about if, it's just when he's going to sign? He's definitely going to sign the Patriot Act extension before year's end, right?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: That's correct. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And so you're deciding whether to do it as an event, or just let us know that he signed it?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Well, as you know, typically, it takes some paperwork and getting the actual bills down here for him to actually sign. So it's just a matter of logistics. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I wanted any White House reaction on the Israeli Intelligence Agency's Chief assertion to the Knesset today, saying that Iran will have the capability to build a bomb in the next two years.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I haven't seen those comments. I think that the administration's views on Iran having a nuclear weapon are very well-known. We, along with the international community, believe that it is a terrible thing for Iran to develop a nuclear capability, and the United States is working with the international community to ensure that that does not happen. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What is your reaction to the calls for re-run of the election in Iraq? And are you concerned that the Sunnis might not be willing to take part in the future government?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I think, so far, the views on the elections in Iraq have been very positive, both by the United Nations, as well as other observers. And so, at this point, I don't think anybody is suggesting that -- I don't think most are suggesting that there needs to be a rerun because it is the belief that the elections were fair. And that is our view, as well. We welcome the process underway to build a permanent government in Iraq, because that is part of the President's vision on the tracks that he laid out in the past few months, which is that Iraq needs to develop the durable, lasting institutions that will ensure its democracy. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Will the President be making any comments in San Antonio, or just privately visiting with the troops?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: We'll let you know.

Okay, given that it's -- I'm sorry, Caren. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q I know you don't want to preview what he's doing, but are the bill signings likely to be public events, or do you think that he'll just sign them at his ranch?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: Well I made an announcement about the President's activity on Sunday, so we don't have anything else to announce at this point. But I don't anticipate anything like that. We'll let you know if the schedule changes. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Last one. The Ukrainian presidency inferred today that it might ask for U.S. to help in solving the issue of the dispute of the gas with Russia. Do you know anything about this? Have you had any contacts?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. DUFFY: I'm personally not. I think that's probably something the State Department will be equipped to comment on at some point, but I'm not aware of that.

Thank you. One programming note: I will -- I'm not planning to gaggle tomorrow, so we'll see you back here on Friday. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Press Briefing by Scott McClellan
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Good afternoon, everyone. I want to begin with talking about matters going on with the Congress right now, particularly the Senate.

The President, as you heard last night, applauds the House for its work to meet key national priorities. The House has moved forward to make sure that our troops have the resources they need to fight and win the war on terrorism. They moved forward to make sure that a vital law was reauthorized for preventing attacks at home -- that is the Patriot Act. They moved forward on making sure that people in the Gulf Coast region who were affected by the hurricanes are getting the help they need. They moved forward on more steps to reduce our dependence on foreign sources of energy. The House also moved forward on making sure that we have what we need to prepare for the threat of pandemic flu, and they also made sure that we're moving forward in a way that spends our taxpayer dollars wisely by passing the deficit reduction package.

The Senate is now finishing up its work, and we urge the Senate to move forward and complete its work on these important priorities. One piece of legislation that I mentioned, the Patriot Act, provides key tools for our law enforcement and intelligence community to disrupt plots and prevent attacks from happening. That law has helped tear down the legal and bureaucratic wall between law enforcement and intelligence officials. It has provided them the same kind of tools they use in pursuing other criminals. The Patriot Act is a vital tool that has helped us break up terror cells here in America.

And a minority of senators continue to filibuster this effort. The Democratic Leader even boasted to political supporters that Senate Democrats had "killed the Patriot Act." A minority of senators need to stop their delaying tactics and stop standing in the way of providing our law enforcement and intelligence community with the tools they need to protect us here at home. We cannot afford to be without this vital law for a single moment in the war on terrorism. It is set to expire, but the terrorist threat will not expire. And it has accomplished exactly what it was set out to do, which is to protect our liberties and save lives. And we urge the Senate to move forward and get this legislation done.

And with that, I will be glad to go to your questions. Terry Hunt. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Scott, the Vice President said today that Vietnam and Watergate had eroded presidential powers, and...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott, the Vice President said today that Vietnam and Watergate had eroded presidential powers, and that he thinks that the world we live in demands strong, robust executive authority. Where would the President like to see his authority expanded? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q No, in general.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: There are three branches of government, they all have an important role to play: the congressional -- the legislative, and the judicial, and then the executive. And we've talked about these issues before. I don't know of anything to add to what the Vice President said. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Last year the President lauded the Patriot Act for giving him tools to track terrorists that he never...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Last year the President lauded the Patriot Act for giving him tools to track terrorists that he never had before, including roving wiretaps and other such tools. If the President has what he needed in the Patriot Act, why the need for this NSA program that he authorized? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But is it a tool that he doesn't have under either the Patriot Act or the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, I just pointed out one of the problem areas that we're trying to fix. And so those -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Okay, if it is a problem area -- is it a tool he doesn't have under either the Patriot Act of FISA?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Those are important tools, as well, and we use those tools. In fact, those tools have helped us address threats, too. But this authorization is an additional tool that we believe is needed for the reason I stated. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I know, but you could have three different types of branches, but if two branches do the job of all three, do you need to have the third?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, absolutely, we need this authority, for the reasons I stated. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What doesn't he have in the Patriot Act or under FISA that he needs to have through this other authorization?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: The President made a commitment to the American people that he was going to use every constitutional and congressional authority needed to fight and win this war on terrorism. This tool has been very successful in helping us to detect and prevent attacks from happening -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Right, but is it necessary with the other tools you have in the Patriot Act?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Yes, for the reasons that we stated. It is very necessary. And remember, there are important safeguards and oversight measures that are in place for this program. The President talked about those just the other day. Every 45 days or so it is carefully reviewed; it must have the approval of top legal officials from the Attorney General to the White House Counsel. The activities that are conducted under this authorization are thoroughly reviewed by the Department of Justice and by the National Security Agency legal officials, including the General Counsel and the Inspector General. There is intense oversight of it, as General Hayden, the Deputy Director of National Intelligence, talked about. And the decisions that are made under this authorization, which is very limited, again, are made by career intelligence officials at NSA. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Yesterday you said that you have consulted with Congress on this, that you briefed members of Congress. So if we can stipulate that as fact, let me ask you, will you cooperate with congressional hearings, should they go ahead?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, I think the President talked about this issue a little bit yesterday. This is still a highly classified program, and there are details that it's important not be disclosed. This program -- the disclosure of this program has damaged our national security and put us at greater risk because the enemy wants to know what we're doing, and by talking about this program it gives the enemy a sense of what we are doing to try to disrupt plots and prevent attacks. And the enemy is sophisticated, it is lethal, it uses new technology to adapt and adjust. And we've got to be able to move quickly, with speed and agility. And that's why this authorization is so important. Technology has advanced a lot and the enemy is making use of it; so must we here at home.

And in terms of Congress, we have briefed members of Congress over a dozen times -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Right, we stipulated that already. Is that --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, the American people need -- I think it's important for them to hear about this, so I want to point that out. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, that's why I mentioned it before I asked the question. So are you saying to members of Congress...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Well, that's why I mentioned it before I asked the question. So are you saying to members of Congress, it wouldn't be a good idea to hold these hearings? Or are you saying, if you hold these hearings, there's not much we're going to tell you? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The President has publicly acknowledged that we went to war under false information, mistaken information. Why does he insist on staying there if we were there falsely, and continue to kill Iraqis?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, maybe you missed some of his recent speeches and his remarks, but the President said it was the right decision to remove Saddam Hussein and his regime from power -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And a right decision to move in and to tell the people, the American people, that it was all a mistake, and stay there?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I don't think he said that. He said that Saddam Hussein was a destabilizing force in a dangerous region of the world -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q That isn't true. We had a choke-hold on him.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: It is true. He was a threat. And the threat has been removed. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q We had sanctions, we had satellites, we were bombing.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Let's talk about why it's so important, what we're working to accomplish in Iraq -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I want to know why we're still there killing people, when we went in by mistake.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: We are liberating people and freeing people to live in a democracy. And why we're still there -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Do you think we're spreading democracy when you spy and put out disinformation and do all the things that -- secret prisons, and torture?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I reject your characterizations wholly. I reject your characterizations wholly. The United States is helping to advance freedom in a dangerous region of the world. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- recognize this kind of --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: For too long we thought we had stability by ignoring freedom in the Middle East. Well, we showed -- we saw on September 11th -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- 30,000 plus?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, Helen, we can have a debate, or you can let me respond to your questions. I think this is an important subject for the American people to talk about. By advancing freedom and democracy in the Middle East we're helping to protect our own security. It's a dangerous region -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q By killing people in their own country?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, I reject that. We're liberating and freeing people and we're targeting the enemy. We're killing the terrorists and we're going after the Saddam loyalists. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The President said 30,000, more or less.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: And you know who is responsible for most of that? It's the terrorists and the Saddam loyalists who want to turn back to the past. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q We didn't kill anybody there?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Our military goes out of the way to minimize civilian casualties. They target the enemy -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q You admit they kill?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, we've got a lot of technology that we can use to target the enemy without going after -- without collateral damage of civilians. And that's what our military does. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Are you kidding?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Oh, I'm going to stand up for our military. Our military goes out of the way to protect civilians. In fact -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Fallujah, we didn't kill any civilians?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: We freed some 25 million people in Iraq that were living under a brutal regime.

Go ahead. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Congress defines oversight as "the authority to conduct inquiries or investigations, to have access...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Congress defines oversight as "the authority to conduct inquiries or investigations, to have access to records or materials, or to issue subpoenas or testimony from the executive." Which of these powers were members of Congress granted with regard to the NSA surveillance program? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But briefing isn't power to investigate or issue subpoenas to ask questions. And I'm asking you, which of the powers of oversight were they granted?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Congress is an independent branch of government. That's what I just pointed out, Jessica. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Which has the right to check the functions of the executive. And these are --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: They have an oversight role, that's

right. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Okay, so in what way --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: That's why we thought it was important to brief members of Congress about this vital tool that we're using to save lives and to protect the American people, and why we talked to them about how it is limited in nature and limited in scope. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But as you know, members of Congress who were briefed said that they were informed -- yes, briefed, but given absolutely no recourse to formally object, to push back and say, this is not acceptable.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: They're an independent branch of government. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q So in what way were they given oversight?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: They were briefed. And we believe it's important to brief members of Congress, the relevant leaders -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Would you also say they were given full oversight?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: They're an independent branch of government. Yes, they have -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Were they given oversight?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Yes, they have oversight roles to play. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q So they have oversight. So, in what way could they have acted on that oversight?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: You should ask members of Congress that question. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Given that the program, to whatever extent we now understand it, has been public for several days now...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Given that the program, to whatever extent we now understand it, has been public for several days now, would the administration support legislation that would more explicitly give the President the kind of authority he has been using under this -- ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But, clearly, you're aware of the concerns of members of Congress who believe that that was not the authority that they were trying to give.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, the Attorney General talked about this yesterday. He talked about how we were briefing additional members of Congress. We've already briefed the leadership and the leaders of the relevant committees, and the Attorney General is going back, talking to additional members about this so that they do have a better understanding of this authorization and what it's designed to do and how it is narrowly tailored and limited in how it's used. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Given that FISA has the retroactive power, the President didn't specifically answer that yesterday, ...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Given that FISA has the retroactive power, the President didn't specifically answer that yesterday, why he didn't elect to use that. And the comments in the earlier briefing, it sort of gives the impression that the administration didn't want the paperwork hassle involved in filing these things retroactively. Is that a fair -- ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q So given the concerns about civil liberties, about oversight, the kind of discourse that's going on since this program has been made public, does the administration feel no change in its conduct in this area is warranted?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: The President has made it very clear, that as long as he is President, he is going to continue using every lawful tool within his power to prevent attacks from happening, and save lives and protect the American people. And that's exactly what we're doing.

Goyal, go ahead. And then Wendell. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Two questions. One, the Vice President's trip to Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan -- is he carrying a...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Two questions. One, the Vice President's trip to Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan -- is he carrying a specific message not only for the newly -- two democracies of Afghanistan and Iraq, but also for the terrorists in those areas -- what you think the President would say -- ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Supporters of the President say that this power to conduct NSA eavesdropping has been upheld by a case that's made it as far as the Circuit Court of Appeals. What's your understanding of that case?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry -- that it has made it as far as? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q The Circuit Court of Appeals.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: In terms of the legal issues? We've talked about the legal analysis, and the Attorney General talked about other rulings that would relate to this that have been upheld by the United States Supreme Court in opinions written by Justice O'Connor. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I know you cited Article II of the Constitution and the congressional authorization to use force in Afghanistan. What's your --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm not going to try to play lawyer from the podium. I'm not a lawyer. But I do know that this President is deeply committed to protecting the American people, and he'll do what it takes to save lives and prevent attacks from happening. He made that commitment when he took office; he renewed that commitment after the attacks of September 11th; and he will do so within our Constitution and our laws. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Another question. It's our understanding this power has been used 18,000-plus times. Are we to presume that there are that many al Qaeda agents in this country?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm not going to get into talking about more than what we've said publicly. That's getting into more than what we've talked about publicly, so I'm not in a position to confirm or deny the numbers that you threw out there. And we don't want to go into greater detail because it's important that the enemy not have a sense of what we're working to do, because they can change and adapt. They can -- and they do. They're constantly changing and adapting. This is a sophisticated and deadly enemy that is constantly trying to change and adapt, and that moves with great speed when they need to. We must move -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- give us an indication of how often this power is used?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: We must move with great speed to stay ahead of them. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q You don't want to give us an indication of how often this power is used, and you don't want to give us an indication of the size of the potential threat in this country>
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: No, I think, again, the Attorney General and General Hayden talked a little bit about this yesterday, but I talked about the nature of this authorization and the scope of it, and I talked about the safeguards and oversight that are in place. This is very carefully reviewed every 45 days and it -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I really don't need you to go there.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, no, but this goes to your question. It is limited to people who have -- one of the parties to the communication have a clear connection to al Qaeda or terrorist organizations, and one of the parties is operating outside of the United States. I think that's important for people to know, because there's been some suggestions that it's spying inside the U.S. That's not the case. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I'll stipulate that. But it is limited to that situation, are we to presume, then, that there are in excess of tens of thousands of al Qaeda agents in this country, because it's been used that many times?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: No, I'm not confirming or denying those numbers. I don't think anyone has done that publicly, so I'm not going to get into a discussion of that nature. But what I will reiterate is that this is very limited and targeted, and that you have to have a clear connection to al Qaeda or a related terrorist organization. And it's the career intelligence officials at the NSA who are making these decisions. These people receive extensive training in acting consistent with what the authorization provides. And that's important for the American people to know. It's important for them to know the parameters of this is very limited in nature. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Is it important for them to know the scope of the threat you perceive?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I think the American people understand that we are in a different kind of war, and understand that we face a new kind of threat from an enemy that changes and adapts, and that getting into talking about some of these operational details endangers their national security, puts us at greater risk.

Intelligence is vital to winning the war on terrorism. Intelligence is vital to winning any war. And this is signals intelligence that we're talking about. It is critical that we have that information to be able to stop attacks from happening before it's too late. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Scott, in April of 2004, President Bush delivered remarks on the Patriot Act, and he said at that time...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott, in April of 2004, President Bush delivered remarks on the Patriot Act, and he said at that time, "any time you hear the United States government talking about wiretap, it require -- a wiretap requires a court order. Nothing has changed, by the way. When we're talking about chasing down terrorists, we're talking about getting a court order before we do so." Was the President being completely forthcoming when he made that statement? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And in terms of the American people, though, when he says "nothing has changed" --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I would have to look back at the remarks there, but you're clearly talking about it in the context, as you pointed out, of the Patriot Act. The Patriot Act is another vital tool. That's why the Senate needs to move forward and get that reauthorized now. We cannot let that expire -- not for a single moment, because the terrorist threat is not going to expire. Those tools have helped us disrupt plots and prevent attacks and break up terrorist cells. We need those tools for our law enforcement and intelligence community. And we urge the Senate to stop the delaying tactics by the minority of senators, to stop their delaying tactics, to stop filibustering, stop blocking this legislation and get it passed. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q So you don't see it as misleading in any way when the President says, "nothing has changed"?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: You're asking me to look back at something that is in relation to the Patriot Act. And it's in relation to the Patriot Act -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q But he's talking about wiretaps --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: -- and I'll be glad to take a look at his comments. I think you're taking them out -- I think the suggestion that you're making, I reject that suggestion. And I'll be glad to take a look at those comments. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Two questions. On the ruling about intelligent design in Pennsylvania, does the President think that ruling should be challenged? Does he have any thoughts on it?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, we weren't a party to the case, so -- and we're not going to comment about the specific legal decision. But I think that the President has made his views very clear. The President has said that such decisions should be made by local school districts. He's long held that belief and he's long stated that belief. The President has also said that he believes students ought to be exposed to different theories and ideas so that they can fully understand what the debate is about. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And then, on Iran, on a follow-up to some of the President's questions yesterday. ...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q And then, on Iran, on a follow-up to some of the President's questions yesterday. In light of the statements and the actions by the Iranian President regarding Israel, and also regarding his own people now, does the White House think the Iranian people should try to overthrow their President? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Scott, on your statement a moment ago about applauding House action on the budget reconciliation bill...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott, on your statement a moment ago about applauding House action on the budget reconciliation bill and the ANWR provision of the defense authorization bill, opponents of the House action say that it would actually impose higher costs on the poor and senior citizens -- with respect to your deficit reduction measure -- that it would cost college students considerably more to pay back their student loans. And with respect to attaching a non-germane provision to the defense authorization bill, Senator McCain called that "disgusting," and other opponents of the non-germane provision said it's a cynical ploy in a time of war. And I'd like to know your response. ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q I'd like to know your response to --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Is that what you're talking about? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- the savings in that, and the ANWR non-germane --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: My response is the President believes that Congress must move forward and meet our national priorities, and also must spend taxpayer dollars wisely. We are doing both. Congress has been moving forward in a way to meet our priorities and exercise responsible spending restraint. The entitlement programs are areas where we can find savings -- and, again, these are savings, it's not reductions that you're talking about that's slowing some of the growth of these programs.

The President outlined a number of steps that Congress could take to find substantial savings for the American taxpayer, while making sure that we're meeting our priorities. And we're going to make sure that the people who need those programs are getting the help that they need. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q But with respect to the statement you also made on lessening dependence on foreign oil, do you object at all to attaching a non-germane provision, unrelated to defense authorization? And, as I said earlier --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: We need to make sure -- Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- it's been objected to by Senator McCain and others, who say it's a cynical ploy in a time of war.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Our troops must have the resources they need to fight and win the war on terrorism. We must make sure that there's no interruption or disruption of the resources that they need to be able to carry out their efforts that are aimed at protecting America and making us more secure.

We also must meet an important economic need here at home, and that is reducing our dependence on foreign sources of energy. Our economy is growing strong because of the policies we have put in place and the tax relief we put in place. High energy prices are still a concern for Americans. We passed the energy plan earlier this year, which will help reduce our dependence on foreign sources of energy. The ANWR provision is another important provision that needs to be passed so that we can reduce our dependence on foreign sources of energy, as well. So we support both these provisions, and Congress -- the Senate, specifically -- needs to move forward and get this done, get these priorities done. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Excuse me, but the ANWR provision was originally included in the Budget Reconciliation Act --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: That's correct. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q -- and was pulled out, and Senator Stevens wanted it in defense authorization because he thought that in doing that, it could pass because everyone wants to pass additional funding for our troops.
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: This is an important piece of legislation, the defense spending bill, to make sure our troops have what they need. And Congress needs to act on it; the Senate needs to get it passed. We also believe it's important to get the ANWR provision passed, and that is vital to our efforts to address high energy prices, as well. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Scott, I have two questions. I understand the White House will soon release a report on Puerto Rico. Can you tell us when, and perhaps give us a sneak preview?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: No sneak preview, but we're very close to releasing that report. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, that's good to hear. Second question: Does the administration plan to assist the new
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Well, that's good to hear. Second question: Does the administration plan to assist the new President of Bolivia, even though Eva Morales is a socialist? Will the President send any representatives to Morales' inauguration? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Scott, I think it was two, or maybe three of the people who were briefed on the NSA program...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott, I think it was two, or maybe three of the people who were briefed on the NSA program said they expressed at least some reservations, and one actually showed us a letter saying he had grave reservations. What was done with those reservations? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Did you take those into consideration? Did those objections lead to any change in the program?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm not going to go further than what I've said, in terms of the briefings that were had. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q You understand that those who criticize you on this are suggesting basically those objections were --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I think I also understand that the American people know what we're doing to try to prevent attacks from happening and save lives. And I think the American people understand the sensitivity of talking about such a highly classified program. The President talked about that yesterday. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Can you at least say they were not ignored?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm sorry? Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Can you at least say they were not ignored?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I don't think we ever ignore Congress. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Well, they said they got no reply. Was the President made aware of Senator Rockefeller's objections?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: You just talked about Senator Rockefeller's letter. I just told you that after that letter there were additional briefings that occurred. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q And he got no reply to the letter, and I'm asking, was the President made aware of that letter?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: There were additional briefings that occurred. The President is very well aware of these matters. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Did the President meet The New York Times editor on December 6th and ask him to not publish the eavesdropping story?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I saw reports about that; I'm not going to get into discussing it, though. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q No confirm, no deny?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: No, neither.

Ken, go ahead. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Scott, are there any kind of surveillance techniques or operations that this administration has considered...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott, are there any kind of surveillance techniques or operations that this administration has considered, but rejected as unlawful? Or is the position in the building that the use of force resolution places no legal limits on whatever the President deems is necessary? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q What about the first?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm not going to get into discussing these matters, national security matters of this nature. There are a lot of discussions that occur. That's why the President made sure that this program was very limited in nature and that it was targeted to address a specific problem. And that's why he also carefully reviews it every 45 days or so. And top legal officials -- both at the NSA and the Justice Department and here at the White House -- review the activities that are conducted under it, as well. And that includes the General Counsel of the NSA; that includes the inspector general at the NSA. That's why we went to Congress and briefed members of Congress about it, as well. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q If it became useful and necessary to listen in on conversations between two people within the United States, does the President believe has the legal authority to do that now?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Well, there are other tools available to us. He talked about that very issue yesterday. FISA is an important tool. We make use of FISA. But this is a difference between monitoring and detecting and preventing. And there are differences here that General Hayden and the Attorney General talked about yesterday, as well. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Scott, how much President Bush is concerned about the stability -- (inaudible) -- will be the flashpoint in 2006, regarding its final status conditional or unconditional --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: This is an issue that I think the State Department has talked about. Nicholas Burns over there has been very involved in this issue. It's an important issue and he stated our views on it. I'll be glad to get you some more information on it, if you want. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q One more. How the President defines the role of Greece since the country -- (inaudible) -- already deployed 1,800 U.S. troops, along with 18,000 --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Let me take a look at it, and I'll provide you with more. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q In reference to yesterday's statements, what is the President doing to push the Iraqi leaders to form a more inclusive government and convince them to reach a compromise --
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Right now we don't know who the Iraqi leaders are; the results are still coming in. But the President has said that it's important that the new government be inclusive and representative. And there's a constitution that's in place that requires a two-thirds vote on forming the leadership of the new government.

But we look forward to assisting and helping the new government once it is in place. Well, let's back up. We look forward to helping the new leaders form an inclusive and representative government. It's up to them to determine the makeup, but we're there to help assist them and move forward as quickly as they can. It's going to take some time because, as I pointed out, the requirements in the constitution. But those requirements are there for a reason, so that you do have a leadership that is representative and inclusive. And we'll look forward to seeing what the results are.

The President spoke with President Talabani and Prime Minister Jafaari earlier today, congratulated the Iraqi people on a successful election. This was an historic moment, and we'll continue to work with them going forward. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Press Briefing by Scott McClellan
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: Good afternoon, everyone. The President looks forward this afternoon to meeting the Iraqi Ambassador to the United Nations, Ambassador Sumaidaie. This will be an opportunity for the President to congratulate the Iraqi people on a successful election yesterday. All indications are that the turnout was broad and -- throughout the country. We congratulate the Iraqi people. It was an historic day for the Iraqi people and for the Middle East and for the world, and it was an historic day for the advance of freedom, which is tied to our own safety and security.

The President had a good discussion with a group of Senate Democrats and Republicans earlier today. General Casey and Ambassador Khalilzad briefed the members on the elections and the political progress, as well as on the security progress. And Ambassador Khalilzad talked about how we would work with the new Iraqi government and assist them as they work to put in place a permanent government. It will take some time to form that government. We urge them to move forward as quickly as possible once the election results are final and they begin to meet, and that it be as inclusive as possible.

General Casey gave an update on the security situation, and another sign of progress was that the violence was down yesterday. However, we know that the terrorists and Saddam loyalists want to continue to carry out their attacks. And we expect that that -- that violence will continue. That's why we've got to continue to work to train and equip the Iraqi security forces going forward. We are making important progress. There are still challenges ahead. At this point, though, we congratulate the Iraqi people for a great day yesterday.

Secondly, the President had some good discussions with some other leaders in the Middle East: the President of the United Arab Emirates, the King of Saudi Arabia, the Prime Minister of Kuwait and the King of Jordan. And he talked to these leaders, and they discussed the successful elections that took place and the high voter turnout, and how violence was down. And they talked about the importance of the formation of an inclusive government.

And the President thanked them for their support and urged them to continue to support the Iraqi people as they move forward on transition -- the transition to democracy. This is a hopeful moment for the region, and we urge all people, throughout the international community, to do their part to support the Iraqi people.

And with that, I will be glad to go to questions. Terry. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

Q Scott, Senator Specter says that the Judiciary Committee is going to make it a high priority to...
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
Q Scott, Senator Specter says that the Judiciary Committee is going to make it a high priority to look into this report that the President authorized the NSA to eavesdrop without warrant on people in the United States. And he says that there is no doubt that this is inappropriate. How do you respond to his characterization of what happened? ... Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Will the Judiciary Committee be part of that oversight, or is that just the Intelligence Committees?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'd just say we would continue to work with members of Congress on these matters. This is about protecting the American people. Read more Comment (0), Email this.
Q Will you cooperate with Senator Specter as the Judiciary Committee looks into this?
seen at in Whitehouse Press Briefings.
MR. McCLELLAN: I'm not sure there's any request that's been made of us at this point. Read more Comment (0), Email this.

 Copyright Statement and About "The Government Says".